Last Friday night, Croydon Council’s auditors Grant Thornton felt legally compelled to publish a damning emergency report on Croydon Council’s finances. These problems have developed over several years and long pre-date Covid. Croydon is the only one of London’s 33 Boroughs in this position. The auditors found a series of staggering failings that have led Croydon to the brink of bankruptcy. The report shows that since 2014 when Labour took control of Croydon Council:
- Labour ignored repeated warnings from the Auditors and from the opposition Conservative Group about the precarious finances going back to 2017, which the report lists in painful detail
- Labour ran the reserves down to dangerously low levels – from £58.2m in 2015/16 down to £16.6m in March this year (before Covid). The auditor says these have been “unsustainably low” for some time, are the lowest in London and Labour has consistently “failed to address the low levels of reserves”
- Labour lent almost a quarter of a billion pounds of taxpayers (i.e. our) money to their wholly owned property developer Brick by Brick, which has failed to repay a single penny – even though £110 million was supposed to have been repaid by now according to their own plans
- Labour ran up the Council’s debt to over £1.5 billion – more than any other London Borough by a large margin
- Labour only made provision to cover a quarter of the repayments on the debt they have run up – these debt repayments are now running at an incredible £43 million per year
- Labour recklessly speculated using our (taxpayers) money on failed commercial property investments without even bothering to formulate and approve a strategy first. This included gambling £53m on buying a secondary shopping centre whose value has now crashed, and gambling £30m on buying Croydon Park Hotel which has since gone bankrupt. The meeting which finally happened to approve the strategy timed out before that agenda item was reached and the plans were approved with no discussion. This is truly staggering.
- Labour’s “approach to borrowing and investments has exposed the Council and future generations of taxpayers to significant financial risk. There has not been appropriate governance over the significant capital spending and the strategy to finance that spending.”
- Labour allowed “considerable overspends” on budgets with little or no proper financial control and “without an appropriate level of challenge”
- Labour used £73m of capital over three years to fund transformation of services (i.e. make them more efficient) but the report finds there has been “little evidence” that any of this worked
- Labour’s “governance over the budget setting and monitoring has not been good enough“
- Labour has covered up its reckless mismanagement of parts of the budget in a way that appears to border on fraud. The report says: “The impact of the overspends has been masked by both the accounting treatment of the Dedicated Schools Grant deficit (which we disagree with) and the use of the flexible capital receipts”
- The Government is now having to send in its own inspectors to make recommendations for clearing up the mess
The full horrifying report from Grant Thornton is here:
Labour in Croydon has shamefully – through neglect, incompetence and most importantly of all by not listening to residents – led the Borough to bankruptcy. This long pre-dates Covid and no other London Borough is in this position.
The very last line of the report says: “Action must be taken to restore the Council to a sound financial position supported by effective governance.” This underlines the need for a Democratically Elected Executive Mayor who will be genuinely accountable to the public and will listen. I am hoping the referendum on this will happen soon now that we have handed in enough signatures to trigger one – although I fear the unaccountable clique running the Council will continue to ignore the public and try to delay holding the referendum as long as they can.
I will keep you updated with further news on Croydon’s financial position.